People Share Their Biggest Personal Mystery That Will Likely Go Unsolved

Training Zone

Have you ever gotten a telephone call from the future? How about waking up on top of your super tall refrigerator, or getting greeted by your boyfriend in the dark despite him still being at work? These may sound terrifying and absurd, but these are just a few true, unsolved mysteries that have haunted their victims for years.

People love a good mystery, and life is full of them — yet when it’s our personal mysteries that remain unsolved, it’s often hard to let them go. Sometimes, even the smallest of life’s absurd experiences resonate with us, and we obsess over an explanation that may never come. While we may not all get the answers we’re looking for, there are some unsolved enigmas that are too odd, wild or disturbing not to share. Can you think of any explanations for these Reddit users’ impossible tales of terror, surprise and confusion?

Must Have Been One Generous Stranger …

A few years ago, I got a citation for $350, but when I went to pay it off, they told me it was already paid for. I asked everyone I knew, and no one claimed they did. I don’t think I’ll ever find out who it was.

Photo Courtesy: Robert Nickelsberg/Getty Images

Yeah, Your Kid Is a Time Traveler

I’ve got three children with pretty unique names. Not unheard of, but not common. My oldest son, Rylan, was nine at the time and sitting on the couch. My cellphone rang, which was weird because it was only used for emergencies. I used my house phone more often, being a stay-at-home mom. I answered it even though I didn’t recognize the number. Here is how the conversation went:

Photo Courtesy: Annie Spratt/Unsplash

Me: Hello?

Teen: Hey Mom!

Me: Um, who is this?

Teen: Mom! It’s me, Rylan!

Me: RYLAN WHO! (Now I’m frantically looking at my son who is very confused.)

Teen Boy: Mom, stop playing! (The phone sounded like a hand was covering the mouthpiece. I could hear another voice say, “No, it’s not time yet.”) Oh, I’m sorry, wrong number …

Whether it was a prank or my kid from the future, I’ll never know. I do know I had to hold onto the wall so I didn’t pass out. I tried to call back about two minutes later and the call disconnected. Super freaky.

You’re Sure She Didn’t Have a Double Life?

My mother died about 12 years ago. At the funeral home, we received a lovely bouquet of flowers with a card from The Red Hot Chili Peppers that said: “We are saddened to hear of Renate’s passing.”

Photo Courtesy: Jessie Daniella/Unsplash

We are a humble family from southern Indiana. There is zero chance she ever had any contact with that band. Is this something they just randomly do? They would have loved her, though. She was the warmest person you could ever hope to know.

Guess They Found a New Setup …

My childhood home in Utah was right behind a farm with regular farm things — horses, chickens, goats, etc.

Photo Courtesy: David Everett Strickler/Unsplash

One day, a peacock showed up out of nowhere and made the farm and our backyard his own home. He cried and cried for weeks. Later, a peahen showed up. They then had babies, and before we knew it, loads of peafowl were all over. They became part of my everyday life. My chores were to feed the peafowl and clean the deck every day. This went on for eight-ish years.

Then, they suddenly just all disappeared.

No one in the neighborhood had any idea where they came from or where they went.

Are You Some Kind of Magician?

I worked at the public library. I scanned a guy’s library card then handed it back to him. Our hands were about a foot apart. Suddenly, the card was gone. It never made it into his hand. We were both totally confused — I looked under the computer, under the desk in the weird cracks, but never found it.

Photo Courtesy: Van Tay Media/Unsplash

I still think about it.

She’s 100 Percent a Water Witch, Dude

When I was little, my babysitter and I were outside and it started to rain. She said, “Watch this,” and walked out onto the empty road. She lifted her arms to form a T-shape, and it started to rain heavier. She put them down and the rain slowed down. She put them back up and it poured again.

Photo Courtesy: Reza Shayestehpour/Unsplash

I’m sure there’s a valid explanation, but for now, I’m still baffled.

Dang, You Were Feeling Pretty Confident

A car followed me home from work one late night. I didn’t know where the police station was, so I stopped on a dark road near my suburb to make sure he was actually following me, and sure enough, he stopped behind me. I got out and grabbed the emergency ax out of my truck without even shutting off the car and started walking towards it, and the car sped off.

Photo Courtesy: Alexei Scutari/Unsplash

I was stupid for doing that, but I will never know who that was.

Sorry, But Do I Know You?

I was traveling in Italy when two American girls came up to me and started talking excitedly about how they couldn’t believe they’d run into me in Rome. They wanted to know how my trip had been going, but I had no idea who either of them was. It was creepy because they knew specific things about my life and my travels that only someone who knew me would have known. I still have no idea who the heck they were.

Photo Courtesy: Adam McCoid/Unsplash

I Mean, I’ve Heard of Colorblindness …

When I was a kid, I started to randomly see nothing but brown. It was usually only in one eye, but it was never the same in both, and rarely in both at the same time. Went to several doctors, and they did some testing, but nothing came up. As I grew older, there was more time between occurrences and now I haven’t had it in close to 10 years.

Photo Courtesy: David Mark/Unsplash

Sometimes it still bothers me not knowing what that was.

Um, This Is Freaking Terrifying

I was working on some assignments at home at like, 9 a.m. I was sitting at the desk in the living room, just on the computer. I could see directly into my housemate’s room from the desk, but since he was asleep, the door was shut. The door was slightly raised off the ground, so you could see if there was anyone standing behind it.

Photo Courtesy: Matt Reding/Unsplash

Suddenly, the door started shaking and rattling as if someone was trying to demolish it, but there was no one behind it. A few terrifying minutes later, my roommate opened the door and said, “Dude, what are you doing?”

I told him, “It wasn’t me, I’m sitting way over here.” We are both flummoxed to this day. What caused that?

That’s an Odd Place for a Nap

The time I woke up on top of my refrigerator.

Photo Courtesy: Latrach Med Jamil/Unsplash

I had been sleeping there, curled up like a cat. To this day, I have no idea how I even got up there. There was nobody home at the time who could have put me up there, and there’s no way I could’ve climbed it unassisted.

I also had no prior history of sleepwalking whatsoever. To this day, I have absolutely no idea what happened, and it still bugs me.

Well, That Took a Wild Turn

Someone came to my parents’ door at 3 a.m., claiming they ran away from home because they were being abused by their father and we were the only people to answer. My parents checked the stranger into a shelter and funded him for weeks. Eventually, he left the shelter and returned home.

Photo Courtesy: Ev/Unsplash

A few weeks later, he started making up lies about my parents, saying they had kept him away from his family for weeks and abused him. To this day, we have no idea if the guy was psychotic or not, but it sure was weird.

… What Do You Mean You’re Not Home?

One night, I heard my boyfriend come home from work while I was sleeping. He came in and said hi, then went out to the living room. I got up not long after to convince him to come to bed, but he wasn’t home. I called him and he told me he had stayed late at work and assured me he had not come home that night at all. I freaked out and made him come home right away. The whole incident creeped me out for a while.

Photo Courtesy: Jp Valery/Unsplash

I Think a Ghost Stole Your Rolex, Buddy

One day, I woke up and my Rolex watch was missing from my bedside table. I was gutted, to say the least; it had enormous sentimental value. I searched the house high and low, but nothing.

Photo Courtesy: Carlos Esteves/Unsplash

About 10 months later, I went to put some boxes on a shelf that required a ladder to reach. Bear in mind, I lived in a Victorian house with high shelves which we NEVER used. My Rolex was there. Still freaks me out.

You Can’t Possibly Have Lost This …

I moved into a new house in July. After unloading all of my things, I realized that I had forgotten some basics like toilet paper and dish detergent. I went out and stocked up on a few things, including a giant pack of my favorite toilet paper with the bears on it, only to realize that my mom had picked some up for me while I was out.

Photo Courtesy: Erik Mclean/Unsplash

This giant pack of toilet paper became a thorn in my side. There wasn’t a shelf or cupboard big enough to store it, so I was always throwing it somewhere.

Then, on the days I needed it, I could never find it. I would search every nook and cranny of my house, but it’s nowhere to be found.

To this day, I still look for that giant pack of toilet paper. I can’t forget. It haunts me. HOW DOES A HUMONGOUS PACK OF TOILET PAPER DISAPPEAR?

Are You Sure He Isn’t an Interdimensional Physicist?

My calculus teacher just kind of materializes out of nowhere. I know what hallway he uses to get to class, so I stand out there and look for him often, but he would never show up. Instead, he would appear with a cup of coffee from a different hallway. It’s like he lives in his own pocket dimension or something.

Photo Courtesy: Tra Nguyen/Unsplash

Sure Wonder How I Ended Up Here …

One day, when I was in eighth grade, I remember being woken up from my bathroom floor by my stepmother. It was around 7 p.m., and I had no recollection of that day. I still wonder what happened … I don’t know how I ended up passed out on the bathroom floor.


It Sounds Like Fate Wants You Two Together

While traveling in the U.S., I arrived in Austin and met an African girl named Wendy. I spent a little time with her — she was nice, but there was nothing special between us. She left a couple of days later, then I left too.

Vitalize Magazine

I took the train to Denver and ended up getting stuck. Because of the delay, I missed my transfer and ended up in Chicago. When I got off the train, there was Wendy, standing on the platform. There were a lot of serendipitous moments during that trip, so I’m perplexed but not surprised.

No Big Deal, Just Warped Through Time

I was working as a projectionist at a movie theater. One of the kids’ movies ended, but the last movie of the night still had about 50 minutes of runtime left. While I waited, one of the things I typically did was check the theater for loose change or unopened candy.

NY Mag

I ran to the theater where the kids’ movie was playing and looked around for maybe 10 minutes. I made my way back upstairs thinking I still had about 40 minutes, and next thing you know, my boss was calling me on the walkie-talkie asking me if I had finished and was ready to go home. I thought he was just messing around, which he sometimes would do, and didn’t think much of it until I realized none of the movies were running.

Did I just somehow just time travel about 45 minutes into the future? Even my watch was wrong. I’ve never been able to explain it to myself, and at this point, I’m just assuming my mind made the whole thing up.

Something’s Not Right About This Picture …

My cousin and I were having a girls’ night at home and went to go grab some wine. I lived in a basement suite that had French doors, which I always locked when I left. When we came back, my cat’s food dishes were sitting on the placemat right in front of the door, with no kibble or water spilled. I usually kept them in the kitchen. It was like someone had displayed them there for when we came back. I saw it through the French doors and we both froze. It freaked me the heck out for a long time.


How Did It End Up There?

I decided to trial a baby gymnastics class with my one-year-old. She was having fun, so I decided to get my phone out to take a few photos. I noticed it wasn’t in my bag, so I figured I’d probably left it in the car. I’d been listening to the Hamilton soundtrack, so it was likely to be there.

The Stir

I finished the class and walked to my car that was parked parallel to the gym. I put the baby in her seat and called out Siri to locate my phone. Siri didn’t answer. I got slightly more concerned than before, but I still got in the car, expecting to see my phone connect to the Bluetooth. I started driving and nothing happened. Now I knew my phone was absolutely not in the car.

I pulled into my mom’s house (who lived two minutes from the gym). I called my number, and to my relief, the woman who answered said I had left my phone at the gym. I thanked her profusely and told her I’d come right back and collect it.

I drove back down to the gym and walked in looking slightly embarrassed. The coach smiled and said, ‘Forget something?’ I laughed and said, ‘My phone.’ Then, she told me to walk around and look for it. I paused. The lady on the phone said she found it. The coach was as confused as I was. She said no phone was handed in and no one had entered the gym since I left. She called out to the two other moms who were there, asking if they had any information. They didn’t.

At that point, I was really confused. I borrowed the gym’s phone to call my phone again. It rang, but no one answered.

I must have stood at the gym desk for five minutes just trying to process what was happening before I asked the coach if I could borrow her phone to use the “Find My Phone” feature. She handed over her phone, and I punched in my details.

The compass spun around a few times, then stopped. I saw my phone on the map, close by. In fact, it was only three streets away … AT ANOTHER GYM. I thanked the coach, drove to the other gym (one I had never entered in my life) and saw my phone sitting on the counter. I asked the receptionist who handed it in but she says she didn’t know. How did it get to the other gym? Where was it found? Who found it and why didn’t they drop it at the first gym?

Come On, Doc, We Need the Full Story

I was a teenager and got a serious neck injury in an accident. I was lying alone on a stretcher in a hallway, waiting for an x-ray. As I laid there, I heard two men coming around the bend in the hallway, talking. I only got a glimpse of them to see that they were both police officers and detectives with their badges and ID hanging around their neck.


“… And then I told him I couldn’t believe it.”

“Well, if you think that is interesting, you should see emergency room six.”

“Why? “

“Well, you know those large, round wicker-rattan chairs?”


“Well, it seems that….”

Then, their voices faded away.

To this day, I wonder about what sort of injury caused by a large, round wicker-rattan chair was worthy of the ER.

I Think You May Have Bought Gatsby’s House …

I live in a historic house once owned by the family of a (former) prime minister of the UK. Besides hearing doors closing and other unusual things, on weekends I can hear loud jazz, 20’s type music and champagne corks popping coming from our living room (just below our bedroom). It actually keeps me up at night.

The Odyssey Online

This isn’t a one time experience. It has happened at least 30 times in the few years we have lived here. I’m an atheist, but the whole thing is really weird.

Maybe They’re Your Soulmate, Maybe They’re Your Mom

Every Valentine’s Day for the last 10 to 12 years, I’ve been sent a “secret admirer” card. Same handwriting, always all caps, always bearing a postmark from a London sorting office. To this day, I have been unable to determine who’s sending it.

Video Blocks

My biggest suspicion is that it’s either my mother or my sister, my evidence being that the cards began when I was in my teenage years when I was a weird looking, very socially awkward teen. There’s no way that someone who wasn’t family would keep it up that long, but I’ve asked them about it numerous times, and they maintain that it’s not them.

I’ve asked other members of my family and they insist it’s not them either. I’ve tried getting angry and imploring the whole family that it’s getting annoying. Yet still, the cards arrive.

Either my family has way more willpower and persistence than I give them credit for, or my mystery admirer will never reveal themselves. Regardless, it bugs me like crazy.

Maybe You’re Invisible?

I once went to a movie by myself when I was living in Georgia for a few months. I was seeing a movie that was several weeks old, so the place was almost completely empty except for a few people in the way front. I sat in the middle seat, in the middle row.


A few minutes before the movie started, a group of friends walked in and decided to sit in my row. They split so that half is on each side of me. They put me in the middle of their group and proceeded to talk over me like I wasn’t there until the movie started. I didn’t say anything because I was so confused and it wasn’t like I could ask them not to use the open seats around me.

But, if they had picked any other row they could have sat together. Why my row? Why split the group around me?

I Sure Hope You Don’t Step on It

I dropped a screwdriver in my bedroom, heard it hit the floor, and then it just disappeared. I never saw it again. I wasn’t even standing, I was kneeling, so it only fell a few inches.


It wasn’t a huge screwdriver, but there aren’t any gaps in my bedroom anywhere that a screwdriver would fit into.

Let’s Not Get Kidnapped Today

My mom and I were doing something at my grandpa’s house while he was out. I was just messing around in the yard when a Mustang came down the street. It was moving slowly enough to be a bit suspicious. Then, it slowed down even more when it started to pass me. So I was just standing there thinking, “What are they doing? This feels weird.”


I became overwhelmed with the urge to run inside the garage as fast as I could, and a split second after that, the car suddenly reversed very quickly. I darted so fast into the garage and hit the button to close the door. I thought maybe I was just overreacting but as soon as the door closed, someone tried to kick it in and they left a huge dent.

I was freaking out trying to tell my mom what happened, but I think she thought I was high-strung or something.

It was the eeriest feeling I’ve ever had though.

Is THIS Your Card?

About a year ago, I found a playing card in my wallet with a scantily clad woman on it. No matter how much prodding I did, my husband and all our friends SWEAR they never snuck it in. I still have it in my wallet and occasionally ask friends about it, but to this day no one has fessed up.

Washington Township

Yep, This Is a Strange Series of Events

I was driving through East London a few years ago with some friends. We were literally just driving for driving’s sake with no destination in mind. We had been out for 10 minutes when suddenly, we saw a series of flashes from the car in front of us. I realized they were taking photos of us. After a few photos, they sped off.

Life And Disability Law

We continued driving for around 40 minutes, and while driving through another part of East London, a person in a totally different car held a camera out of her car window and started taking photographs again. After a few photos, she sped off too, this time skipping through a few red lights.

Another 20 minutes later, we drove into a parking lot, and I realized we were being followed by yet another car. I’d take a left and they would take a left. I’d take a right, and they would too.

I was just about ready to floor it because I didn’t know what the heck was going on. Then, suddenly, blue lights turned on. The car that was following us was an undercover police car. I got pulled over, and two undercover cops came up to the car, asking me to get out. They showed their badges, checked my license and details, peered through the windows of my car, and eventually let me go on my way.

I don’t know if these were three completely unrelated incidents, but it didn’t sit right with me that I was being photographed in my car, miles apart, with both cars speeding off, and then later pulled over by police for my first time ever.

Welcome To The Family, Stranger!

My fiancé and I come back to our apartment after being away all day. We got in, dropped our bags off and walked into the kitchen. Sitting on my counter was a picture of an African American girl. It was like a senior portrait with the name “Brandy” on it.


My fiancé and I are Caucasian, and we don’t know anyone named Brandy. I know the door was locked and nothing else seemed out of sorts. So, naturally, I framed it, and now Brandy is an unofficial member of our family.

Brandy, if you are out there, we love you. Come visit.

I Guess The Ring Loved You, Too

I was given a diamond and emerald ring on my birthday. I was obsessed with the ring and wore it every day.


When I was 17, I went on a date to watch a movie. During the movie, I put my hand in my purse that sat on my lap, and when I pulled it out, I felt the ring slip off and heard it clink on the floor.

I instantly panicked and started feeling around as much as possible. I even used a flashlight to look for it.

Sadly, nothing. When the movie ended, we had a whole crew searching, I called the theater many times over the following weeks and no one ever saw it.

When I was 20, I was cleaning out a drawer when something pricked my finger. When I pulled out the item, it was the emerald ring.

I never wore it again for fear of losing it.

Dude, I Swear They Weren’t In My Pocket

I went to a buddy’s house after work to return a tool that I’d borrowed. We had a beer and chatted for a bit. I went to leave and I couldn’t find my car key.


At the time, I kept my car key on a separate fob. I had my house keys, but no car key. I checked all my pockets. The key wasn’t in the ignition or visible in the car. I then searched the yard.

Finally, he drove me home to get my spare key. When I got home, I reached in my pocket for my house keys and pulled out my car key.

I had literally turned my pockets out. It wasn’t there before. It just wasn’t.

Welp, That’s A Fantastic Way To Wake Up

One time when I was in university, I went out on Halloween and blacked out. I woke up with all my clothes soaking wet, and a black eye. It hadn’t rained the previous night and to this day I still have no idea how I got soaked or what happened to my eye.

Video Blocks