What's Hot| Upload Video| Email this Page| Your Account

Mcclellan's War: The Failure Of Moderation In The Struggle For The Union

-- Finalist for the 2006 Peter Seaborg Award for Civil War scholarship --

This biography of the controversial Union general George B. McClellan examines the influences and political antecedents that shaped his behavior on the battlefield, behavior that so frustrated Lincoln and others in Washington that he was removed from his command soon after the Union loss at Antietam. Rather than take sides in the controversy, Ethan S. Rafuse finds in McClellan's politics and his desire to restore sectional harmony ample explanation for his actions. Rafuse sheds new light on the general who believed in the rule of reason and moderation, who sought a policy of conciliation with the South, and who wanted to manage the North's military resources in a way that would impose rational order on the battlefield.

"Rafuse's book . . . offers the most comprehensive account of McClellan's prewar life and military career available, buttressed with a convincing analysis, and is sure to alter current perceptions and future assessments of the general's role in Civil War history." --Providence Sunday Journal   more

BestDeal

$26.44 at Amazon
  • From: Amazon
  • Posted: May-19-2009

A for effort

Rafuse has come to praise Mcclellan not to bury him and that alone makes this an interesting effort, as you'll be hard put to find too many works out there which favor Little Mac. The author strives mightily to put Mcclellan in the context of his time and present him as a Man of Reason. He...

Read full review | Report as inappropriate
  • From: Amazon
  • Posted: May-16-2007

The Smoking Gun on Little Mac

Sailing around the world, U.S. Grant sighed that George McClellan was one of the chief enigmas of the war. A century and a half later, most Civil War buffs would agree. McClellan's biographers either considered him a hero or, in the case of say Stephen Sears, a delusioned man who flirted with...

Read full review | Report as inappropriate
  • From: Amazon
  • Posted: Mar-23-2006

Clausewitz was right

What a delightful rendering of General George B. McLellan from Ethan Rafuse. I don't know if this treatment will restore Little Mac from the severe wounds history has inflicted on him but it does help us understand why he behaved the way he did. Politicians always slather thick layers of...

Read full review | Report as inappropriate
  • From: Amazon
  • Posted: Feb-04-2006

A fine piece of scholarship

George Brinton McClellan's legacy since the Civil War has been largely criticized by historians and the general public. Hundreds of books generated notions that the Union high command prior to U.S. Grant's arrival was full of generals who could not win battles or take the initiative in...

Read full review | Report as inappropriate
  • From: Amazon
  • Posted: May-08-2005

A full review of the question

Finding a general in American history with as bad a reputation as George B. McClellan is not an easy task. Few Civil War books have anything good to say about him, fewer still defend his actions in the field. His victory at Antietam is often listed as a draw or even a Confederate victory. This...

Read full review | Report as inappropriate

MoreStores

10
Page 1 of 1

SimilarProducts

close
close

More legal stuff: Smarter.com is a comparison shopping website that compares prices and products at online stores to help consumers save money. Stores are responsible for providing us with accurate price and product information, including the proper codes for coupons, discounts and rebates. Tax and shipping costs are estimates. Please confirm all costs before making your final purchase at the online store. All merchant ratings, product reviews and video reviews are submitted by shoppers or third-party websites. We are not responsible for their content. If you have any concerns about content on our website, please contact us.