What's Hot| Upload Video| Email this Page| Your Account

Battle: A History of Combat and Culture

A noted military historian offers a cultural approach to the history of warfare, insisting that we understand combat best when we study the beliefs, values, and expectations of the adversaries.

Battle: A History of Combat and Culture spans the globe and the centuries to explore the way ideas shape the conduct of warfare. Drawing its examples from Europe, the Middle East, South Asia, East Asia, and America, John A. Lynn challenges the belief that technology has been the dominant influence on combat from ancient times to the present day. In battle, ideas can be more far more important than bullets or bombs. Clausewitz proclaimed that war is politics, but even more basically, war is culture. The hard reality of armed conflict is formed by - and, in turn, forms - a culture's values, assumptions, and expectations about fighting. The author examines the relationship between the real and the ideal, arguing that feedback between the two follows certain discernable paths. Battle rejects the currently fashionable notion of a "Western way of warfare" and replaces it with more nuanced concepts of varied and evolving cultural patterns of combat. After considering history, Lynn finally asks how the knowledge gained might illuminate our understanding of the war on terrorism.  more

BestDeal

$20.90 at Amazon
  • From: Amazon
  • Posted: Mar-07-2009

Complementary readings to Lynn's book

There are already several good reviews to this book, so I will only suggest reading the following books in addition to Lynn's book: 1) above all, "War in human civilization" by Azar Gat; 2) "War before Civilization. The Myth of the Peaceful Savage", by Lawrence Keeley; 3) "How War Began" by Keith...

Read full review | Report as inappropriate
  • From: Amazon
  • Posted: Oct-07-2008

Essential reading for anyone interested in military history

Awesome book! Lynn's model on the discourse versus the reality of war is invaluable for every student of military history. Even though this is high level scholarship the book is very reader friendly. Apart from creating his own model Lynn should also be given credit for effectively disarming...

Read full review | Report as inappropriate
  • From: Amazon
  • Posted: Apr-20-2007

Thoughtful

This very good book is devoted to the ways that larger culture influences how different societies wage war. Lynn presents a series of essays looking at how classical Greece, ancient China, Enlightenment Europe, and others waged war and the ways warmaking reflects important cultural features....

Read full review | Report as inappropriate
  • From: Amazon
  • Posted: Mar-09-2007

Battle Joined

John Lynn's "Battle" is a well-written and incisivelook at an important historical subject. In a timeof war, it is an important reminder of the lessons ofhistory. Colorful examples and thoughtful commentarycan be found throughout this tremendous work.

Read full review | Report as inappropriate
  • From: Amazon
  • Posted: Mar-01-2006

A Cultural view of Military History

A very interesting discourse on the culture of warfare. He brings an interesting point of view to the table regarding how our culture determines the way we go to war. There has been some discussion on a 'western' way of going to war. And his analysis begins with the Greeks first defining the...

Read full review | Report as inappropriate
  • From: Amazon
  • Posted: Dec-23-2005

Interesting analysis ... until the Epilogue

"Battle" appears to be written as a direct challenge to Victor Davis Hanson and John Keegan, two of the world's best known military and classical historians. Dr. Lynn's book is well written and well organized, and provides a fascinating overview of his thesis on how cultural discourse affects...

Read full review | Report as inappropriate
  • From: Amazon
  • Posted: Aug-07-2003

Definitively studies the history of war worldwide

A work of impressive scholarship by noted expert on seventeenth and eighteenth-century warfare John A. Lynn (Professor of History, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign), Battle: A History Of Combat And Culture From Ancient Greece To Modern America definitively studies the history of war...

Read full review | Report as inappropriate
  • From: Amazon
  • Posted: Jun-13-2003

Harshly critical of Victor Davis Hanson

Lynn completely disproves Hanson's thesis about the Western way of warfare in the opening chapters of Battle. Lynn cites the examples of the ancient Chinese and Indian armies as having the same organization of the ancient Greek armies although they were not based on democratic ideals. The Chinese...

Read full review | Report as inappropriate

MoreStores

10
Page 1 of 1

SimilarProducts

close
close

More legal stuff: Smarter.com is a comparison shopping website that compares prices and products at online stores to help consumers save money. Stores are responsible for providing us with accurate price and product information, including the proper codes for coupons, discounts and rebates. Tax and shipping costs are estimates. Please confirm all costs before making your final purchase at the online store. All merchant ratings, product reviews and video reviews are submitted by shoppers or third-party websites. We are not responsible for their content. If you have any concerns about content on our website, please contact us. For more information, please view our Privacy Policy.